Columns

Reporting

  • "Made in the Shade"
    A package on Southern writers: profiles, interviews and an 11-state directory of writers you may never have heard of but are worth your time. Appeared in Creative Loafing chain.
  • "Mass Appeal"
    A day-in-the-life profile of a telegenic parish priest in Miami. Published in Catholic Digest, reprinted in the St. Petersburg Times
  • "The Liberation of Tam Minh Pham"
    How the first West Point graduate from South Vietnam disappears after the fall of Saigon, only to be rescued by his classmates two decades later. A cover story in The Washington Post Magazine

Fiction

« Plagiarizing imagery | Main | From Africa, a boy soldier's tale »

Say it again, Sam.

So I’m driving to work the other day and a news report about the death of famed  50’s crooner and songwriter Frankie Laine  comes on the radio.

A phrase jumps out. “In a prepared statement, the family said... .”

“Prepared statement?

What’s the converse: an ”unprepared“ statement.

My colleague, style watchdog Scott Libin, wondered if an unprepared statement requires that ”the words would appear in random order.“

There seems no doubt: prepared statement is redundant. Limit it to ”statement.“ You lose none of the meaning and trim your story by a word.

Stay alert for redundancies in your prose, omitting those speed bumps that distract a listener/viewer/reader.

p.s.I initially described Scott Libin as ”ever-vigilant language watchdog.“ But watchdogs, by their very nature, are expected to be ever-vigilant, as opposed to asleep at the switch. Out went ”ever-vigilant,“ The meaning’s preserved while the story is a two-word hybrid shorter.

You can listen to samples from Laine's "Greatest Hits" album on this amazon.com page.

Comments

I agree. It's even worse when, and I see this often in the papers, reporters write, "He read a prepared statement..."

If I had a hamster I'd line its cage with articles like this.

Excellent point. I would take it even further and banish "said in a statement." I mean, if someone says something in song or in a finger-painting, I think that's worth noting, but usually a simple "said" will suffice. "Said" and "stated" mean the same thing, so "said in a statement" is redundant. Usually the reporter is trying to point out that it was a written press release and not a live statement, but there are better ways of doing that. (Like "said in a news release.") ...Sorry for the rant. I'm on a quiet and lonely crusade to stamp this out at my newspaper.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Recent Posts

April 2008

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30      

Favorite Blogs, Sites

Blog powered by TypePad